The Lode

Hancock school’s roof partially collapsed

Edzordzi Agobozo, Lode Writer

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






On Feb. 24 this year, Local 3 News reported a bus garage collapse in Negaunee Public Schools as a result of heavy snow pile up on the roof of the building. Sixteen busses were trapped inside the debris. Almost a month later, another school building’s roof collapsed in Hancock.

On Wednesday Mar. 14, Local 3 reported that the roof of Barkell Elementary School in Hancock has collapsed. The collapse was attributed to combinations of heavy rain and heavy snow. The walls beneath the collapsed section also bowed outward. By the time the school authorities discovered the collapse on Thursday morning, some of the students were already in the school. Authorities decided to closed down the school and bus the elementary school students to the middle and high schools on Campus Drive. They dismissed students from the other grades.

Reacting to the news of the collapsed roof, Stefka Hristova, a parent and associate professor in the department of humanities of Michigan Tech said, this is “a school in crisis. You can see the layers and layers of compacted snow!” Adam Wellstead, a resident of Hancock and associate professor in the department of social sciences at Michigan Tech also commented “Who would have ever guessed that thousands of pounds of snow on a flat roof might be a problem? Shocking!”

Superintendent Kipp Beaudoin and a team of volunteers assisted to relocate the students and to help clean up the debris. “I want to thank the city, law enforcement, public works. OHM came over immediately and offered their assistance to us, and again the community has rallied, and we’re really appreciative,” Beaudoin said. The Superintendent’s Office later announced the cancellation of school for Friday.

According to Keweenaw Reports, more roof collapses were recorded in the Upper Peninsula within the same period. These collapses included a winter storage building in Baraga County Fairgrounds, Keweenaw spring restaurant in Baraga County and a vacant retail space on Fifth St. in Calumet that was once home to Family Dollar.

1 Comment

One Response to “Hancock school’s roof partially collapsed”

  1. John Loosemore on March 23rd, 2019 11:26 am

    Stefka Hristova is correct about the layers! You can see multiple layers, and you know each storm only leaves one layer.

    After the collapse, school district officials immediately claimed that the snow had been removed and that this was the result of a single blizzard, but right away I noticed there is no real snow pile on the ground below the rear roof… more like a general drifting there. The snow piles which came off the front roof (which is the same width) were huge, originally like one continuous slope from roof to ground. Even after the warm spell and rain they still stood as high as the eaves in many places. That the front roof was left that long before clearing is scary in itself, in view of how district officials were fully aware that the roof had defective trusses. But worse yet is this evidence that shows the rear roof was NEVER cleared. At the time of the collapse, even after the warm melt-down and the rain, it appears there was about 5 feet of snow on the roof in some places. Over 5 feet of snow left on a roof they knew was defective, when they knew rain was coming! After all the front-page news stories about collapsing roofs? And after the Negaunee school-related collapse, which should have especially woke them up? How reckless — how negligent — are these people? My daughter goes to that school.

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




The Student News Site of Michigan Technological University
Hancock school’s roof partially collapsed